A8 Parts Forum

A8 Parts Forum (https://forum.a8parts.co.uk/index.php)
-   For Sale and Wanted - Cars (https://forum.a8parts.co.uk/forumdisplay.php?f=115)
-   -   Want Audi estate for my wife -- please advise (https://forum.a8parts.co.uk/showthread.php?t=14221)

roberto 9th June 2018 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142499)
Understood Adrian. Thanks!!

So today I'll be viewing the car that you suggested:
https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01803274962346

Will let you know the output...

*** If anyone has an opinion about reliability of this car please post here asap ***


Update: Tried to check tax rate via Roberto's link https://vehicleenquiry.service.gov.uk/ViewVehicle
and I get:
"The vehicle tax rates are only available if you have the latest 11 digit reference number from the V5C registration certificate (logbook)"

Hope this won't attract dreaded £540 p.a. bill

1. it looks a good car and they tune well i think if thats your intention
2. its another link for tax prices but as long as its less than 226 ie: 225 or less your ok
3. £290 that car
4. service history is very important (check spark plug changes) they are expensive so nobody does them the Tips broke off a friends car and he had to get another engine

notorious 9th June 2018 11:37 AM

Got it. Cheers Roberto !!

Adrian E 9th June 2018 03:11 PM

Presume you're mainly looking just to see if it's the right sort of car for you and your wife?

If seriously considering buying then:

Check s-tronic service done on or before schedule (38k advised on mine)
Ideally annual services, but most are on longlife
Plugs should be done around 57k/6 years
Supercharger belt is due at about 60k miles (and might as well do the auxiliary belt at the same time, as it involves pulling the front end into the service position)

These are based on a pre-2012 so the service book may indicate a different interval (or in the case of the supercharger not quote an interval at all!)

My invoice for spark plugs quotes £12.99 each for them, but we had the car on a service plan which covered the cost entirely so labour isn't broken down.

The only fault ours has suffered from is a failed thermostat at pretty much bang on 50k miles. Not sure if later cars suffer with it, but the supercharger needs removing to change it. Ours was covered by the warranty (circa 6 hours labour to change according to Audi book)

Report back soon!

notorious 9th June 2018 09:11 PM

Looked at the car.
Cosmetically very nice example in and out.

Drives very nicely.
And yes, very low RPM on top gear @ 70mph.
On S-series car. After world of D2s I find it fascinating...

Unfortunately, the car was clearly driven by someone who does't love cars.
Someone who loves driving, but not cars.
Scratches here and there in interior. Not major ones and most interior trim can be replaced to fix the issues, but driver clearly 'didn't care'.

My 2002 D2 looks far better from interior condition point of view than this 2014 car.
So, it is not STUNNING like they describe it.
Just OK condition.

Dead fly in the headlight. How fly could get to the headlight? This is beyond me.
Dead spider in the tail light. How he got there? Bad design/ sealing?
Headlight and taillight look OK to me. Not misty or milky. No mechanical damage.
Just perplexed how insects got inside...

No transparency with servicing.
No receipts.
All they have is 4 stamps in service book from **independent** Audi specialist. No single Audi stamp.
I can understand why they did this -- I hate Sytner with passion.
BUT God knows what was actually done with S-tronic, etc. Have they serviced it properly?
Engine doesn't seem to leak anywhere, but you have to put car in the air to really inspect.

The car was driven by daughter of 'business partner' of the establishment, who is now on vacation in Croatia returning back on Monday.
That explains to me why some buttons are so scratched -- women's long nails :)


Here comes the shocking part.

D2 width mirror to mirror is 1973mm.
This A4 avant width is 2040mm.
That's right, A4 is 67mm **WIDER** than D2. Jesus Christ.

When my wife realised the prospect car is almost 7cm wider than our D2 (which she thinks is quite monstrous in size),
she said she's unprepared to switch to it from her current Fiat Punto manual. I can understand her.
I’ve had no idea either about how wide the damn thing is...

I loved the car overall. Interior scratches can be fixed. Flies and spiders can be removed from lights.
My wife was shocked with width.

Next steps:

It looks like we need to see A3 / S3 with her... Just to see how it compares.
(Another shock: A3s are only 7mm narrower than D2 mirror to mirror. But perhaps it looks smaller visually)
They are about the same price on Autotrader as A4 cars.
Clearly, there won't be as much legroom at the back though.

Anyone knows about post-2013 era A3/S3s? Are they any good? Long term reliability? ...

roberto 10th June 2018 04:34 AM

wow!
that's the trouble with buying cars
some peoples immaculate is another person's poor condition
i went to look at an immaculate 2012 Q3 for my wife it was Dirty
and they wanted dealer retail price
when i said that the woman said How Rude !
personally i would stay away from autos if she will drive manual
sounds like you are after the so called (unmarked example inside and out car)

maybe your postcode might help folk on here to make suggestions close to you so you are not travelling far and wide to look at poor cars

All newer cars are wider and getting wider But parking spaces are NOT :(

here's more reds :-)

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01805146501794

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01805317040555

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01806027090191

notorious 10th June 2018 06:35 AM

Yeah, Lots of surprises.

I’ll actually travel for a good example.
Last time I brought D2 I travelled to Edinburgh from Reading area.

Do you see any good Petrol candidates?
It looks like we have had consensus with Ian that Petrol is less complicated hence more reliable in the long term.

Adrian E 10th June 2018 06:49 AM

The thickness of the D2 doors was always what made it mega wide to park for me - the exterior mirrors don't stick out much from the outside of the body if you look down the side of the car. Our S5 (which is wider than the A/S4) would fit in the garage with ease with the mirrors folded in, and the fun and games I had getting the S8 in are well documented! If it 'feels' too big for your wife, then it probably is. If you're both just going off the numbers I'd not worry about it if she's happy with driving it and the interior space.

If the width is a sticking point then try the Octavia - it's closer to A3/Golf width but without the loss of rear legroom or a big boot. It's a great family car and I would've bought one if the Golf hadn't come up. They have the benefit of being popular with private owners so tend to be better specced once you've swerved the ex-lease ones.

The post 2013 A/S3 are good cars - basically a Golf with quattro, but without the theft risk of a Golf R. The Sportback has significantly more headroom than the 3 door hatch, but could no way be described as an estate - it's a 5 door Golf hatch. The Golf is at least as practical and in estate form a lot more practical than the A/S3.

As for car dealer's descriptions - they're all pretty much universally as bad as each other. If you're not buying brand new you're taking pot luck on condition. We got lucky with our privately owned Golf GTI at a year old - it's rare to find anything that hasn't been car washed by cretins in supermarket car parks or had bird poo left on it for weeks.....you get lucky, or you don't....

Skoda in 'primer' but with leather and memory seats as a minimum

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01805246832897

White and decent spec

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01806047147972

Kermit green (looks great) and decent spec - newest shape. Think it gets ACC as standard?

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01805016099146

Big benefit as a long term ownership proposition is how new a car you get for the money

Private sale Golf R? Dull colour though. Having had a look I think it's only the R that comes with the option of the 2.0T engine

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01803114475798

Adrian E 10th June 2018 06:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142547)
Do you see any good Petrol candidates?
It looks like we have had consensus with Ian that Petrol is less complicated hence more reliable in the long term.

I wouldn't touch a diesel as a family runabout now - too much exhaust aftertreatment which knocks fuel economy to the point there's little real world difference in running costs. Plus the cost of repairs is eye watering - stats I've seen suggest the average life expectancy of a diesel is now a good few years less than petrol - used to be the other way round when diesels were still mechanical injection. They are great if you live on the motorway and need 600 mile range, but for anything else in car terms they've had their day.

notorious 10th June 2018 08:18 AM

Thanks again Roberto and Adrian.
Step by step I get aligned with reality.

I think we will spend Sunday viewing newer A3.
Still undecided which one, but perhaps this (Hopefully this newer, but simpler example wasn't trashed yet and is still in good condition)
https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01805106387392
Edit: OOPS, this one was sold -- perhaps this was a clean example :)

going to see this one: https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01805246841869
Gutless engine, but will give an idea of size of the car, hopefully to convince the wife to test drive it :)

Then we'll need to decide:
1. Do we actually need A4 or should it be A3 (or other A3 class car)
2. Shall we look for newer car to ease search hopefully to get an example in truly good condition, (from someone who actually loved the car and took care of it)
3. Shall we take waiting position for an older cart example to emerge in the market in equally good condition.

briang9 10th June 2018 01:30 PM

This also gives you tax rates

https://totalcarcheck.co.uk/

good luck with the search+++

notorious 10th June 2018 03:07 PM

Ice is broken. Today my wife test drove Manual Petrol A3 at Reading Audi and liked it in principle.

** The car that is only 7mm narrower than D2 mirror-to-mirror **

So, will be looking for:
* Petrol & Manual A3 or S3
* Post 2013 as advised by Adrian
* Quattro or non-quattro dosn't matter
* 1.4 or 2.0 TFSI. Ideally 2.0
* would be nice Nav High
* would be nice Apple CarPlay
* would be nice Sunroof
* Colour strictly Misano Red

Anything bad about these cars that ew need to know? Anything to avoid?

budget up to 20k

IT 10th June 2018 10:51 PM

7 Attachment(s)
Some A3/S3 brochures for you, in case you dont have them.....

27litres 11th June 2018 05:54 AM

Hmm C6 RS6... Only car I'd replace the D2 with...
...naughty, mustn't think like that :tuttut:

How big a car do you want? B7 A4, or C6 A6 both seem the logical choices to be able to get a nice V6 or V8 in.



Did I miss something Ian?
Quote:

His Toy - 2002 Audi S8 D2 GmbH demonstrator. Exclusive Aqua Blue paint, Navy blue leather dashboard and door tops, Individual electric rear seats, Factory rear seat entertainment with DVD player, TV tuner and extended centre console, Exclusive tan leather with Exclusive Tan carpets and floor mats. Exclusive tan alcantara roof lining and parcel shelf. Exclusive tan leather controls pack. 20" 9 spoke alloy wheels, blinds.

Edit: bit late with my $0.02! Sorry, loaded this page hours ago and just read it missing the updates!

notorious 11th June 2018 06:37 AM

Cheers Ian.
You're right, we don't have brochures yet. Thanks !!

1781cc 11th June 2018 06:49 AM

I'd say drive an A3, see how you get on, but as a comparison piece, find an A6 3.0 TDI Le Mans and see how it feels, know that with a remap its a mega car as well. They drive pretty spectacularly for a diesel estate

Adrian E 11th June 2018 06:51 AM

If you settle on A3 size, try a Golf. I think they’re more practical and they’re definitely a bit cheaper for same spec. Love ours - drives great and you only miss quattro in the damp months

notorious 11th June 2018 07:47 AM

Cheers Adrian.
Will look at Golf, but something is telling me it’ll be A3 :)

Is s-tronic relibale on A3 platform?
Currently only considering manual.

notorious 11th June 2018 07:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 1781cc (Post 142602)
I'd say drive an A3, see how you get on, but as a comparison piece, find an A6 3.0 TDI Le Mans and see how it feels, know that with a remap its a mega car as well. They drive pretty spectacularly for a diesel estate

Thanks. Will be wife’s car :) Looking for petrol only.
Settled on post 2013 A3 platform

IT 11th June 2018 09:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 27litres (Post 142596)

Did I miss something Ian?

I've had it 6 months..... Brought it out at the annual meet and updated my sig at the same time..... Happy to chat in a new thread about it, don't want to mess up this thread.... +++

Adrian E 11th June 2018 10:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142611)
Cheers Adrian.
Will look at Golf, but something is telling me it’ll be A3 :)

Is s-tronic relibale on A3 platform?
Currently only considering manual.

Hiya

Very reliable - 6 speed unless you go for one of the very newest, which are 7 like the s-tronics in the S4. They're smoother to drive in the Mk7 Golf compared to the B8/8.5 platform A/S4 as I think they've got the software more resolved.

Personally I'd only buy an auto - it just lends itself to stop-start and town driving. The 6 speed auto pulls very sensible revs on the motorway on these later cars. We test drove a previous generation S3 Sportback and that seemed too rev-happy on the motorway, but that won't be an issue if looking at later shape as you are.

Re Golf vs A/S3 I actually prefer the Golf to look at. Just seems better resolved. Standard spec kit is better on the Golf (buy a GTI and you get adaptive cruise as standard) and if you look carefully you can find some with spec on them.

HPsauce 11th June 2018 10:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adrian E (Post 142629)
Personally I'd only buy an auto - it just lends itself to stop-start and town driving.
.
.
.
.
adaptive cruise as standard

Both I'd say are an absolute must these days for almost any type of driving on public roads. +++
Modern auto gearboxes (especially the 8-speed or more versions) are seamless and typically more fuel-efficient than a manual.

If only you could retrofit adaptive cruise to a D2...… :love:

notorious 11th June 2018 03:08 PM

Thanks again Adrian & Andrew

Perhaps we should consider s-tronic then !
We will be looking at year 2017 cars, i.e. 'slightly used' lastest generation A3s.
Don't known how wife will test drive s-tronic though cause she never sat in car with automatic.

Golf looks appealing with adaptive cruise in GTI.
Should revisit this again.

notorious 11th June 2018 03:46 PM

Adrian,

Did Audi publish any statements about life expectancy of latest S-rtonics?
I know manual will probably outlast the engine, but how about the dual clutch thing? If serviced properly of course.
Also, can they be reconditioned like old ZF hydraulic gearboxes? Or are they ‘sealed for life’?

HPsauce 11th June 2018 03:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142644)
Don't known how wife will test drive s-tronic though cause she never sat in car with automatic.

Almost the same issue here when test driving before buying our Volvo V40; the ONLY automatic SWMBO had ever driven in recent years was my old S8, and then very very rarely.

However, she was "on board" with the logic of getting an auto and soon got used to it. And she loves the ACC. +++

Adrian E 11th June 2018 03:50 PM

On the Golf there’s very little difference between our 2015 and the facelift that came out last year (referred to as Mk7 or Mk7.5) apart from the option for a bigger option nav screen. Ours has the biggest option screen for the time and has all the toys you’d want

My advice for novice auto drivers is always to forget you’ve got a left leg - you don’t need it! Driving s-tronic style boxes doesn’t really require a different technique to a normal auto

Adrian E 11th June 2018 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142645)
Adrian,

Did Audi publish any statements about life expectancy of latest S-rtonics?
I know manual will probably outlast the engine, but how about the dual clutch thing? If serviced properly of course.
Also, can they be reconditioned like old ZF hydraulic gearboxes? Or are they ‘sealed for life’?

I’m not aware of anything published (they’d be risking claims for any car that failed to meet their expected lifespan if they did!)

Just to give you an indicator, mate has a Skoda Superb that he uses for airport runs. It’s coming up to 7 years old and has done near enough THREE HUNDRED THOUSAND MILES with just routine servicing on the dual clutch box

paulrstaylor 11th June 2018 08:23 PM

Am I going to get lynched for suggesting you also look at a Volvo!? Possibly a V60?

HPsauce 11th June 2018 08:30 PM

Love our Volvo V40, but it's relatively small, so depending what you need a V60 sounds good.
Though, that said, an A3 was (for a short while) a similarly-sized contender for us. Lost out on lack of tech, which tells you a lot!

Plus points of V40 - really safe, top quality, lots of tech options. 5-door hatchback ONLY (no estate or saloon options).
Possible downsides - realistically 4 good seats; fitting 5 adults for a long trip is not a good idea (local trips are fine). Boot is quite small.

And for your budget you may be looking at an older one; the newer models with the VEA engine range are IMHO better.
Only the top-of-range T5 Cross-country (which we have) is 4-wheel drive and faster than my S8 (up to about 100mph). No longer available new, not that you would care.

Most autos have a 6-speed Aisin (Borg-Warner as was?) box, the T5 has a superb 8-speed one. The extra speeds are really "overdrive" ratios for relaxed cruising.

HPsauce 11th June 2018 10:19 PM

If you're bored (or intrigued) and want to read our tale of starting by test driving an A3 and ending buying a V40, look here: http://forum.a8parts.co.uk/showthread.php?t=11019

notorious 13th June 2018 03:56 PM

2 Attachment(s)
Team,

Thanks everyone for helping me!

Today drove all the way to King's Lynn (!!) Audi to view this car
https://www.autotrader.co.uk/classif...01803064313334
and purchased it.

Lipstick red 2017 A3 Sport 2.0 TFSI 190hp
with S-tronic, Adaptive Cruise Control & Apple CarPlay
(the car which is only 7mm narrower than D2 mirror-to-mirror)

14,000 miles, £18,400

This was epic. Thanks again for all your help.

Low RPM @ 70mph :)

http://forum.a8parts.co.uk/attachmen...1&d=1528905344

http://forum.a8parts.co.uk/attachmen...1&d=1528905344

roberto 13th June 2018 04:19 PM

lovely.... good choice

steamship 13th June 2018 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142746)

Nice car. How did you manage to take that photo whilst having both hands on the wheel? I've heard of using your phone hands-free, but this beats everything.

HPsauce 13th June 2018 04:40 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Liking your front gates. +++
Reminds me of the "score my gate" contest we had on the Wild Atlantic Way trip...….

Talking of which, we passed this pair not far from the Durker Roods Hotel that gets an honourable mention!

notorious 13th June 2018 05:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by steamship (Post 142749)
Nice car. How did you manage to take that photo whilst having both hands on the wheel? I've heard of using your phone hands-free, but this beats everything.

With my front teeth and tongue :ROFL:

1781cc 13th June 2018 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by notorious (Post 142752)
With my front teeth and tongue :ROFL:

Bet your wife is happy! :ROFL:

Adrian E 13th June 2018 06:19 PM

Great stuff - glad you've found something without too much aggro. Car shopping for us is usually a 6-12 month process from initial idea to finding the ideal car :ROFL:

tonupkid 13th June 2018 06:58 PM

Love it and I'm sure your wife will end up wondering how she ever faffed about with a clutch and gearstick. Great choice

briang9 13th June 2018 07:03 PM

Very nice+++

notorious 13th June 2018 07:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adrian E (Post 142755)
Great stuff - glad you've found something without too much aggro. Car shopping for us is usually a 6-12 month process from initial idea to finding the ideal car :ROFL:

Cheers Adrian.
You convinced me to get S-Tronic instead of manual !!

Spanker 13th June 2018 07:42 PM

Just like to echo the thoughts of others. A beautiful car. I wish I could afford one :o

As for the colour...... Meh! :ROFL:


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:59 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.