Someone crashed into my A8

[audifin]

Originally Posted by sarg

OK, let me explain

You said " just as she was opening the door another car came from behind and hit the door" which is not anything like the same as "if you open your car door with no traffic around"

Maybe it was the latter and you were just embellishing the story a little?

Sure, if the door had been open for some time, I'd agree you're completely not to blame, it's just not how I read it from your description.

This is what she wrote to the statement to the insurance company: "I was opening the door to come out when the other car hit the door". The written statement was 3 pages long with photos, map, diagram etc etc. and before that she gave a verbal statement over the phone. Naturally the other party would have given their statements too.

As Norretal says, you don't know any of the circumstances, how can you form an opinion? Let alone make accusation of dishonest insurance claim, pretty serious accusation.